Tuesday, July 26, 2011

Presentation Reflections

1  1.)   What are some of the best things you saw during the presentation?  Why do you like them?  What were the most effective teaching strategies you witnessed?

I thought that overall the presentations that everyone gave were fabulous.  Everyone, with the exception of Erin, used Prezi.  I’ve never seen or used Prezi before, but I can see what a great tool it can be for a presentation if it’s used correctly.  Some people had really unique ideas for setting up their Prezi’s.  I like how Jerry used a rattlesnake image to weave through his presentation.  It was creative of him to come up with that.  I thought that idea made his presentation run more smoothly.  It provided a good flow.  Probably the best thing I saw during the presentations was Sara’s improvisation when she ran into a technical problem with Prezi during her presentation.  I think she wanted to show a clip of Middle English speaking.  When it didn’t come up for her, she did it herself.  Suddenly she just starts speaking in Middle English!  This was surprising and impressive.  Instead of getting flustered and tongue tied during her crisis, she remained cool.  She spoke up in that language.  I was very impressed with the way she handled that.  Also Cassandra was impressive.  Her teaching strategies are well done.  She is confident and engaging.  She calls on students to answer questions.  At the same time she is roaming around the room and staying active.  You can tell she has done this before and is completely at ease when she is presenting in front of a class.  I wish I could say the same for me.  A few of the presenters encountered some technical difficulties (Sara, Ryan, and Roger).  This is something that is bound to happen to every teacher at some point in their career when using technology.  The key is how you handle the situation when it arises.  I thought all of them handled it very well.  I already pointed out how impressed I was with Sara when it happened to her.  But Ryan and Roger did a nice job too.  They remained calm and played it off real well when their respective crisis’s struck.  They each continued talking and presenting despite the fact their videos weren’t playing.  This took the attention away from the problem because we students still had to listen.  

2  2.)  What were the least engaging/helpful things you saw during the presentations?  Why were they not effective?  What could any specific student do to improve? 

An issue that came up for a few people, that certainly weren’t helpful, was the technical difficulties that arose.  I think these folks might have had too many video clips that caused delays.  I’m not real good at understanding this technical stuff, but I’m guessing it was too much for the system to handle.  Too many videos were causing the clips to keep buffering and not playing.  They might want to cut down on this to prevent it from happening next time.  Another thing that was not engaging was the few instances where I thought some presenters were reading the texts.  I know it can be easy to fall into this trap because I’ve done it myself before.  It’s important to avoid this because students can start to lose focus in what you are saying when this happens.  Middle and high school students can have pretty short attention spans.  If you allow them to time lose focus by simply reading and boring them, you can ruin your presentation.  That can also come in danger of happening when you have delays with buffering videos.  Technical issues and reading are two things you must attempt to avoid when doing these presentations. 

4 comments:

  1. Brandon,

    Thank you for your comments. My big question for you is how are you going to incorporate your feedback of our presentations into your coming presentation. What will you do about incorporating videos into your presentation to prevent delays? Will you vow to not read off of the slide? What positives do you want to "steal" to use in yours? How will this translate into a more professional and put together presentation for you? Can't wait to see it!!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. BRANDON!!!!!

    I totally agree with you, Sara did an amazing job when her video failed to open – I only hope that I’ll be able to do the same when technology fails in my classroom. Remember when Paul Pick told us (multiple times) how teachers are also good actors … this technique may come in handy during these situations ☺ I’m excited to see your presentation. As Erin mentioned in her comment – I hope to see ways in which you learned from the other presentations. You mentioned that reading from the slides can be distracting and that there’s a potential for students to lose focus. How will you adapt your presentation so that students won’t lose focus? Also, you’ve mentioned that you’re a “digital immigrant”. As a fellow blueberry, feel free to ask questions or if you need any assistance when dealing with technology, please don’t hesitate to ask ☺ I know learning different tech programs can be super hard and we’re a team –always willing to help ☺

    ReplyDelete
  3. Presentation Reflection Cont.

    3. After viewing everyone else’s presentations, how would you improve your own (both how you presented and the project you made) the next time you were to give this presentation?
    After giving my presentation, I noticed several ways I could improve. First I can’t cross my arms while I’m presenting anymore. I really didn’t noticing I was doing it. I guess it was a subconscious thing I was doing. I basically did it the whole time I was standing up there. I felt comfortable with the material I was going over and what I was saying. However my body language said otherwise. Shawn told me after the fact that folding your arms indicates to your audience that you aren’t confident with what you are saying. Or maybe he said that it shows you are nervous? It was something along those lines. I was confident in the presentation I was giving. I had no trouble explaining what I was presenting. I knew the material backwards and forwards. But I was nervous a little bit. I’ve really come along way though since the beginning of summer when I was petrified to get in front of the class. I’m now much more confident. But a bit of nervousness lingers in me. So next time, no arms crossed! Also I’d give a bit more eye contact to my audience. I did look and talk to the screen too much. But again I think I’m improving on this too. Previously I was doing it a lot more. Now I’m doing it less, but I need to do it even less frequently. The Prezi I did was pretty good. I really had no problems with my videos or the whole set up, with one exception. I had one slide that was tilted at an angle. So it didn’t look even like the rest of my photos. It was a minor mistake that I didn’t really notice beforehand. So next time I think I can clean things up a little bit, but overall I’m pretty happy with my presentation.
    4. Do you like using power point/prezi/smartboard as a lesson presenter? What are the pros and cons of using it? How might you use it with students? If you could go back to Friday, would you have tried a different one than what you chose?
    I like using Prezi now that I’ve gotten the hang of it. It was very, very, hard for me to figure out at first. I had quite a bit of trouble with the technical aspect of it. I’d zoom in too close, and then I’d zoom in too far. I don’t know if it was my computer or the Prezi program, but it felt like I was trying to operate a runaway train. The controls just wouldn’t cooperate with me. It felt like I was moving all over the place. Finally I was able to get used to it better, and then it wasn’t so bad. I also was confused with the instruction wheel up in the right hand corner. At one point I lost where it went and I couldn’t find it for an entire day. I think I was in show mode and then I didn’t find the tab on the screen that allows it to come back. It was such an easy solution, I’m embarrassed to say it, yet it really caused me grief. So the cons are that it can be confusing until you get the hang of it. The pros all come after you get the hang of it. It’s really neat cool it works. It can flow smoothly along the path once you’ve made it. I like how neat it looks when it finished. The pictures and videos are easy to use, that also makes it great. If I was to go back to Friday, I would not choose to use power point or smartboard. I’m so happy with the way my Prezi turned out. It just sucked that I had to go through so many problems in the beginning. But now I know it and I’ll never have that problem again.
    5. After this project, what do you believe is the best way

    ReplyDelete
  4. Presentation Reflection Cont...

    5. After this project, what do you believe is the best way to deliver lecture materials (no electronics is an option)? How often do you think you will utilize an electronic presentation method to deliver your content and what might you use instead/in addition to? Why do you think you will present material that way?
    I think the easiest way to deliver lecture materials is with no technology. The reason I say that is I’m so bad at using those things. But I really need to learn them because they should be used. So the easiest way and the best way aren’t the same to me. Once I can grasp the technology I will use it because it really enhances your lecture. The visual aids are great. I think I’ll use Prezi now and then. When I need to deliver a lecture that I feel needs some visual enhancement, I’ll create a Prezi. But I won’t use it every time because I can imagine it would be time consuming to make one for every lesson I teach. I think instead of a Prezi I can also use other technology such a voice recorder or a camcorder. I think these might be simpler for me to use, but ask me after Monday.

    ReplyDelete